Showing posts with label question. Show all posts
Showing posts with label question. Show all posts

Friday, June 17, 2011

MPs question aid money for India

14 June 2011 Last updated at 21:01 GMT The BBC's Mark Dummett reports on the impact of UK aid in Orissa in eastern India.

The UK must "fundamentally" change its aid relationship with India after 2015 by giving less to the increasingly prosperous country, MPs say.

The international development committee backed the government's decision to continue providing ?280m a year in the short term to combat poverty.

But it called for a redirection of money towards priorities such as improving hygiene and education.

The government said this "endorsed" its own approach to aid for India.

The UK continuing to help India while the south Asian nation's own government spends large sums on projects such as a space programme has attracted criticism.

The coalition has promised to spend 0.7% of gross national income on overseas aid and India is the biggest single recipient of that aid.

In its report the committee agreed with ministers that the existence of "large pockets of poverty" within the country justified the maintenance of UK aid for the immediate future.

'More rigorous'

But it expressed concerns at a lack of experience within the Department for International Development (DfID) in dealing with the private sector, through which half the money is expected to be invested.

They demanded "greater clarity" on which projects would be the most effective.

Continue reading the main story Mark Dummett BBC News, Nuapada, India

Thousands of lives in one of India's poorest regions have been transformed by British aid.

Nuapada in Western Orissa was often hit by drought, and hunger was a regular part of life.

But British experts revived the arid landscape, digging wells and irrigation ditches.

Now farmers can grow four crops a year. Reservoirs are full of water and fish.

The project has been so successful that the Indian government is replicating it over a vast area.

But should the UK be helping India at all?

While Britain is cutting back, India is expanding its social services. It has a space programme, nuclear submarines and even recently offered $5bn of its own aid to Africa.

India now has more billionaires than the UK, and it clearly no longer lacks money. The challenge is making sure that everyone benefits.

Britain's Department for International Development and other aid agencies think they still have a role to play while so many Indians remain mired in poverty.

DfID also needed to be "more rigorous" in choosing initiatives to support and give more attention to improving sanitation and reducing social exclusion, the committee said.

Its report said: "We support the UK's continued development assistance to India for the period up to 2015.

"However after this the development relationship must change fundamentally to one based on mutual learning and technical assistance where requested."

The committee's chairman, Liberal Democrat MP Malcolm Bruce, said: "The test of whether the UK should continue to give aid to India is whether that aid makes a distinct, value-added contribution to poverty reduction which would not otherwise happen. We believe most UK aid does this.

"The Indian government has primary responsibility for poverty reduction. It has put up taxes and increased its social spending, but the poverty there is on such an extreme scale that it will take many years for India to achieve internationally agreed Millennium Development Goals."

However, Oxfam criticised the setting of arbitrary deadlines for the potential end of financial aid.

Senior policy adviser Max Lawson said: "This report clearly shows that UK aid plays an important role in tackling poverty in India, a country with more poor people than the whole of sub-Saharan Africa.

"MPs are right to say that we should keep our aid under review. But future aid to India should be determined by the needs of poor people there and the ability of their government to help them, not by any arbitrary deadline."

A DfID spokesman said: "We're glad that this report by the cross-party International Development Committee endorses our approach to delivering aid in India."


View the original article here

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Rape question

19 May 2011 Last updated at 11:27 GMT Rape victim (posed by model) Justice Secretary Kenneth Clarke has been heavily criticised for talking about "serious rape" as compared with other types of rape. But can some rapes be viewed as more serious than others?

The justice secretary's remarks suggesting some rapes were worse than others has led to a storm of protest and demands for his resignation from Labour.

Speaking to BBC Radio 5 live on Wednesday, Mr Clarke appeared to draw a distinction between date rape and "serious rape, with violence and an unwilling woman". Put to him that "rape is rape", he said: "No, it is not."

He says he used the "wrong choice of words" and insists he regards all rape as a serious crime. But can some be viewed as more serious than others?

"I come from the position that rape is rape," says criminologist Prof David Wilson of Birmingham City University, who has worked on the sex offender treatment programme at Grendon prison.

Continue reading the main story 13,991 recorded offences of rape of a female in England and Wales in 2009-101,174 recorded offences of rape of a male in England and Wales in 2009-102.3% of females and 0.5% of males say they have been a victim of sexual assault in the past yearSource: Home Office recorded crime statistics and British Crime Survey"If we listen to what the victims of rape tell us about its impact, there is no difference between those who have suffered date rape and those who have been attacked by strangers.

"Often the victims of stranger rape will generate more sympathy, which seems to me absurd. We mustn't ever give out the message that your rape isn't as bad as someone else's rape."

Those who work with rape victims agree. They argue there is no sliding scale when it comes to the impact of rape and the violence involved.

"Rape is a man having sex without gaining permission from the woman," says Eileen Calder, who has worked with rape victims for decades and is the co-founder of the Belfast Rape Crisis Centre.

"How he does it and his relationship to the woman are insignificant. I have worked with rape victims for 26 years and violent, stranger rape is in some ways easier for women to deal with. The guilt and shame women have in a situation when extreme force hasn't been used is immense."

Continue reading the main story
What I think he was trying to explain was that some offences of rape are punished more heavily than others”

End Quote Joshua Rozenberg Legal analyst Julie Bindel, a feminist campaigner who has worked with rape victims, says too often society classes "real" rape as being snatched off the street by a stranger and violently assaulted, everything else is something that just went "a bit too far".

"But I know women who have been raped by their husband or a friend and find that awful because they have been betrayed by someone they trust. The rape is attached to a part of their lives they rely on - their family or their job. It has a horrific psychological effect."

But as well as the impact of rape on the victim, Mr Clarke's comments also show a lack of understanding of what today's law actually is and how it is interpreted by judges, says Clare McGlynn, professor of law at Durham University.

In two cases this year alone the Lord Chief Justice has made a point of saying one type of rape is no less serious than another, she says. In a case in January Lord Judge told a court to approach rape within a relationship, including marriage, as "no less serious than rape by a stranger".

Justice Secretary Kenneth Clarke Clarke had been talking about plans to halve jail terms in return for a guilty plea

Again in March he spoke of a case involving multiple rapes by a husband of his wife.

"This case may have lacked extreme violence, but it certainly included significant violence," he said at the time. "As between these two features, the violence in a stranger rape case and the betrayal of trust in the relationship case, the end result is to look at the offence through the eyes of the woman who is the victim."

But Mr Clarke's defence that he used the "wrong choice of words" is understood by some. Legal analyst Joshua Rozenberg says all offences of rape are serious and he is sure the justice secretary "wishes he had said that".

"What I think he was trying to explain was that some offences of rape are punished more heavily than others, depending on whether there were aggravating or mitigating circumstances.

"The courts would never say that they treat some offences of rape more seriously than others, but they acknowledge that some offences are punished more severely."

Christopher Kinch QC, chairman of the Criminal Bar Association agrees that "aggravating features" can mean some rapists receive longer sentences, but adds that you shouldn't label certain rapes as "more serious".

"Rape is always a serious offence," he says. "It's punishable with a maximum of life imprisonment so it's one of the most serious offences on the book. There are other types of rape with more aggravating features, but it is not helpful to label them as more or less serious."

Continue reading the main story For single offence of rape by a single offender...For victims aged 16 and over range of 4-8 years custody (starting point five years)For victims aged 13-15 range of 6-11 years custody (starting point eight years)For victims under 13 range of 8-13 years custody (starting point 10 years)Aggravating factors: Abduction, detention, abuse of trust, sustained attack, rapist knew he carried sexually transmitted infection, more than one offender, offence motivated by prejudiceRepeated rape of same victim over time has range of 13-19 years custody (starting point 15 years)Mitigating factor: Victim engaged in consensual sexual activity with the offender on the same occasion and immediately before the offenceMaximum penalty for rape: Life imprisonmentCPS covers England and WalesBut such misplaced words have a drip, drip effect on people's attitudes, say those who work with rape victims. They say Mr Clarke's talk of "serious rape, with violence and an unwilling woman" just fuels society's preoccupation with the physical violence involved in a rape.

"Most people don't believe a woman unless she has a black eye or a split lip, some obvious sign to suggest something happened that wasn't very nice," says Bindel. "But women can have very significant physical injuries you can't see... internal injuries. Then there is the psychological hurt.

"There is a real mythology about rape - that it's extremely rare and the perpetrators are crazed strangers who strike on a dark night. People don't want to accept that ordinary men can rape."

Calder agrees: "People separate rape from reality, think of it as a horrendous crime that happens to someone else. If they think of it in this way it takes away the fact that any man can be a rapist."

Reporting by Denise Winterman, Tom de Castella, and Jon Kelly


View the original article here