Showing posts with label inquiry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inquiry. Show all posts

Monday, July 18, 2011

Press inquiry 'overdue' - Blair

14 July 2011 Last updated at 16:19 GMT Tony Blair with Rebekah Brooks in 2004 News International backed Labour throughout Mr Blair's time in office Tony Blair has said a review of the way politicians interact with the media is overdue, claiming he was "uncomfortable" with the relationship while he was prime minister.

Mr Blair told the BBC there should be an "honest debate" about the issue with each side setting out their views.

But he declined to talk about his own relationship with News International.

As Labour leader he courted the Murdoch press but attacked the media in general shortly before leaving power.

Mr Blair welcomed the public inquiry into press standards, regulation and Westminster's dealings with the media to be launched in the wake of the phone hacking scandal at the News of the World.

'Free and vigorous'

He insisted the media must remain "free, independent, vigorous and investigative" and be allowed to pursue stories in a "proper way".

But he said it was time for a "open and frank" rethink of their relationship with politicians in light of recent events and technological changes which had revolutionised news gathering and reporting and the way people consumed information.

"I think the sensible thing is get it all out and let's have a honest debate about it.

Continue reading the main story
I think most of us who have been at the top in public life over the last few decades have been uncomfortable with this relationship and the way it works”

End Quote Tony Blair "I have wanted this for a long time. I think most of us who have been at the top in public life over the last few decades have been uncomfortable with this relationship and the way it works."

While both sides had their own needs, Mr Blair said politicians still remained dependent on the media for speaking to the public and communicating policy.

"The sensible thing now is to have an investigation which we put everything out there and the politicians explain their problems when they are dealing with incredibly powerful media people."

In opposition and then as prime minister, Mr Blair was often accused by critics of getting too close to News International - the owner of The Sun and The Times which supported Labour through his decade in No 10.

'Feral beast'

In his autobiography, he said he grew to admire Rupert Murdoch - boss of parent firm News Corp - despite the media mogul's right-wing views, describing him as an "outsider" who had "balls".

Shortly before stepping down from office in 2007, Mr Blair took the press to task for what he said was their cut-throat competition and obsession with 24-hour news cycles and personality politics.

He compared the industry to a "feral beast", saying it "tore people and reputations to bits" and threatened politicians' "capacity to take the right decisions for the country".

But despite singling out specific titles for criticism, he did not highlight any Murdoch publications.

"I did not get much support at the time (for the speech)," he said. "But this is a major issue."

Mr Blair, who did not own a mobile phone while he was prime minister, has described the recent revelations about hacking as sickening.

His successor as prime minister, Gordon Brown, launched a scathing attack on News International on Wednesday, accusing it of "illegal activity on an industrial scale".

He also sought to distance himself from the company, claiming he did not have a "cosy or comfortable" relationship with its newspapers despite his own efforts to cultivate them.


View the original article here

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Hayman defends hacking inquiry

13 July 2011 Last updated at 12:26 GMT Andy Hayman Andy Hayman wanted to know why MPs were laughing The former Chief Constable of Norfolk, Andy Hayman, is no stranger to controversy. During his time in charge of the force he introduced big changes which didn't go down well with everyone.

Then he joined the Metropolitan Police where he was dogged by allegations about his private life, his expense claims and a couple of botched anti-terrorist operations.

And now the retired assistant commissioner finds himself at the heart of the phone hacking scandal.

He appeared before the Home Affairs Select Committee supposedly to re-assure them that his original inquiry had been as thorough and professional as possible. But he left MPs exasperated.

'More Clouseau than Columbo'

"Quite incredible," exclaimed Cambridge MP Julian Huppert (Lib Dem) at one stage.

"The public will see you as a dodgy geezer," said Lorraine Fullbrook, the Conservative MP for South Ribble.

Any suggestion that these were cosy candlelit dinners where state secrets were shared is rubbish - it was often with our director of comms and they were business-like”

End Quote Andy Hayman Former Chief Constable of Norfolk

"More like Clouseau than Columbo," said chairman Keith Vaz (Lab, Leicester East).

Mr Hayman oversaw the original inquiry which resulted in the conviction of the News of the World's royal editor and a private investigator. But while the inquiry was going on he continued to have dinners with journalists from News International.

Mr Hayman didn't see anything wrong with this. "Any suggestion that these were cosy candlelit dinners where state secrets were shared is rubbish. It was often with our director of communications and they were business-like," he said.

Michael Ellis, the MP for Northampton North, suggested that it was improper for a policeman to have dinner with journalists while they were being investigated. Mr Hayman did not accept this.

"There is no way I'm going to disclose to them what's going on... not to have had that dinner would have been more suspicious than to have it."

At that point the room burst into laughter: "Why are you laughing?" demanded Mr Hayman.

"We are astonished by your answers," replied Mr Vaz.

'Grubby' allegations

Mr Hayman gave the impression that there wasn't much to worry about.

He said the recent revelations about phone hacking were "a horror story" but he believed that the inquiry which he oversaw was well run. It would have been investigated more deeply, he said, if he had had more resources.

He described as "grubby" allegations that were made in the New York Times suggesting that News International had threatened to publish allegations about his private life if he dug too deep.

"Any hint of being in their back pocket is unfounded - I refute that," he said.

"Even if I had a motive that was unethical, how could I have ever stopped a line of investigation? Peter (Peter Clarke, his deputy) and SOI (special branch) would have instantly been on to me."

And as for taking a job as a columnist with the Times, he said it was a "different stable" and he had no problem working for the company which he had investigated.

Mr Vaz concluded the session saying that he normally summed up a witnesses' evidence but on this occasion he felt that Mr Hayman's evidence "speaks for itself".


View the original article here

Broad powers for hacking inquiry

13 July 2011 Last updated at 15:12 GMT David Cameron told MPs if Andy Coulson lied he should be prosecuted

The judge leading the phone hacking inquiry will have powers to call media proprietors, editors and politicians to give evidence under oath, the PM said.

Lord Justice Leveson will oversee the public inquiry into the News of the World scandal and media regulation.

David Cameron said those who sanctioned wrongdoing should have no further role in running a media company in the UK.

The family of murdered Milly Dowler, whose phone was allegedly hacked, said they were "delighted" at the inquiry.

The prime minister held talks in Downing Street with Milly's parents, Bob and Sally Dowler, and sister Gemma - the third such meeting the family has had with senior politicians since revelations emerged that Milly's phone messages were allegedly accessed after she went missing in 2002.

Meanwhile, NoW's parent company News Corporation has dropped its bid to take full control of BSkyB.

Following fresh revelations about alleged malpractice at News International - News Corp's UK newspaper arm - Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt had referred the company's bid to acquire the 61% of shares it does not already own in the broadcaster to the Competition Commission.

The Commons was due to debate a Labour motion - backed by the Conservatives, the Lib Dems and smaller parties, calling on Rupert Murdoch's company to drop its bid.

Meeting editors Continue reading the main story Culture, practices and ethics of the pressTheir relationship with the policeFailure of current regulationContacts made and discussions between national newspapers and politiciansWhy previous warnings about press misconduct were not heededIssue of cross-media ownershipIn a statement, Lord Justice Leveson said his "inquiry must balance the desire for a robustly free press with the rights of the individual while, at the same time, ensuring that critical relationships between the press, Parliament, the government and the police are maintained".

He added: "The press provides an essential check on all aspects of public life. That is why any failure within the media affects all of us."

Earlier, Mr Cameron told MPs the inquiry would begin as "quickly as possible" and would be in two parts - an investigation of wrongdoing in the press and the police and a review of regulation in the press.

He said Lord Justice Leveson, assisted by a panel of senior independent figures, would make recommendations for a better way of regulating the press which "supports their freedom, plurality and independence from government but which also demands the highest ethical and professional standards".

He will also make recommendations about the future conduct of relations between politicians and the press.

Mr Cameron told MPs he will require all ministers and civil servants to record meetings with senior editors and media executives to help make the UK government "one of the most open in the world".

Mr Miliband welcomed the proposals, arguing it must be imposed retrospectively, so that he and Mr Cameron publish all details of meetings with media executives dating back to the last general election.

Continue reading the main story Lord Justice Leveson

Lord Justice (Sir Brian) Leveson became a barrister in 1970 and a QC 16 years later.

The 62-year-old was made a High Court judge in 2000 and appointed to the Court of Appeal in 2006. He was senior presiding judge there from 2006 to 2009 and now, as chairman of the Sentencing Council, is responsible for criminal sentencing policy in England and Wales.

Lord Justice Leveson is well known for being the barrister who led the prosecution case against serial killer Rose West, who was jailed in 1995 for the murder of 10 women and girls.

He was also the judge during the 2006 trial over the murder of 10-year-old London schoolboy Damilola Taylor.

In March, the Sun, a News International title, called him a "softie" for "introducing proposals to let 4,000 assault convicts a year go free rather than face jail".

Mr Cameron was previously criticised for meeting Mr Murdoch in Downing Street soon after the election, partly because Mr Murdoch did not walk through the front door.

Newspapers which did not support the government ran stories of "secret meetings".

Earlier, at prime minister's questions, Mr Cameron said a "firestorm" was engulfing parts of the media and police, and those who had committed offences must be prosecuted.

Mr Miliband said it was an insult to the family of Milly Dowler that Rebekah Brooks was still News International's chief executive.

Mr Cameron responded: "She was right to resign, that resignation should have been accepted. There needs to be root and branch change at this entire organisation.

"What has happened at this company is disgraceful - it's got to be addressed at every level."

Mr Cameron also told MPs that his former head of communications Andy Coulson should be prosecuted if it is proved that he lied when he claimed to know nothing about phone hacking at the News of the World while he was editor.

On Tuesday, Mr Cameron met Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg and Labour leader Ed Miliband at Downing Street to discuss the hacking scandal.

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson is believed to have updated the three men on the current state of the police inquiry into hacking claims when he visited Number 10.

In other developments:

Mark Lewis, solicitor: "The Dowlers are delighted that there will be a full, judge-led inquiry"

Meanwhile, Labour's communications chief Tom Baldwin is facing renewed questions over claims he handled private information which was gained illegally during his years at the Times newspaper, another News International publication.

The former Conservative deputy chairman Lord Ashcroft makes the allegations in a blog posting on ConservativeHome, which he owns. Mr Baldwin has not responded to the claims.

On Tuesday, former senior police officers told MPs the original inquiry into phone hacking did not get the attention it deserved because other duties would have been neglected, and News International failed to co-operate with them.

Sir Hugh Orde, president of the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo), said it was now time for News International to explain themselves - as the police had done, and hand over any evidence of corruption among police officers.


View the original article here

Saturday, July 9, 2011

PM 'too slow' over hack inquiry

7 July 2011 Last updated at 15:59 GMT Conservative peer Baroness Rawlings said Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt will not rush his decision on the BSkyB takeover

Labour leader Ed Miliband has accused David Cameron of failing "to react with the necessary speed" to the phone hacking scandal.

He urged the prime minister to "show leadership" and set up a wide-ranging, judge-led public inquiry immediately.

The government plans to announce the remit of two inquiries into the issue before Parliament's summer recess.

Meanwhile News International has announced that this Sunday's edition of the News of the World will be the last.

The company's chairman James Murdoch told staff on Thursday: "The News of the World is in the business of holding others to account. But it failed when it came to itself."

It follows reports that relatives of soldiers killed in Iraq and Afghanistan may have been the victims of hacking.

Earlier Mr Miliband said he was "absolutely horrified" by the allegations and their emergence made it even more important that an inquiry was set up quickly to investigate hacking, regulation of the press and the relationship between the police and the media.

He added: "The prime minister has a very close relationship with a number of the people involved in this...

"I think he should ignore those relationships and come out and say the right thing because that is what the country expects."

'Burning outrage'

Mr Cameron has said any probe cannot actually begin until the police investigation into hacking is complete. He is due to meet Mr Miliband next Wednesday to discuss the inquiries.

Leader of the House of Commons Sir George Young said the government was planning two inquiries - one into the police handling of the original hacking investigation, and one into the actions of the media.

He said ministers would consult widely on the remit of these inquiries in the coming weeks, including with Commons privacy committee and members of other parties, and would announce their decision before the recess begins on 19 July.

Conservative London Mayor Boris Johnson is among the figures who have demanded faster action from Mr Cameron.

Continue reading the main story Norman Smith Chief political correspondent, BBC Radio 4

Downing Street say no final decision has yet been taken over whether to place a judge in charge of the hacking inquiry - but it's hard to see how that can be avoided.

For a start, any inquiry may follow possible police prosecutions and therefore will require someone with the background and brain to navigate his way through the potential legal pitfalls.

There is also a desire at the top of government to ensure any inquiry commands public confidence and is not seen as a whitewash or an establishment stitch-up.

Finally, both Ed Miliband and deputy prime minister Nick Clegg back such a move and therefore David Cameron would leave himself politically exposed if he were he to decide against a judge-led inquiry.

Those around Mr Cameron say he wants to take his time to get this right - and has an "open mind" - but it's hard to see why he would choose not to have a judge in charge.

"I certainly think there should be a judge-led inquiry and I think it should be immediate," he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme, adding that the hacking allegations had left him with a "burning outrage".

"I think there should be no holds barred. Get the editors, get the proprietors in and let's hear exactly what has been going on."

Mr Johnson also said there should be "external validation" of the Metropolitan Police's inquiry into its own handling of the case, adding: "There has to be confidence that this is not just the police washing their dirty linen."

Labour MP Chris Bryant, who has been a vocal campaigner on hacking and secured an emergency Commons debate on the subject on Wednesday, agreed that steps could be taken now.

"I think you need a statutory inquiry to be set up now. It probably wouldn't meet in public now but it would be set up," he said.

"It would have its terms of reference [decided]. It would have the power to summon evidence before somebody starts shredding it either at News of the World of the Metropolitan Police."

Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg has also contacted all of his MPs to assure them he will be pushing for a judge to be appointed.

Takeover bid

The Royal British Legion has severed its links with the News of the World over the latest allegations about service families.

The move follows the decision by a growing list of companies, including Ford, Boots, Asda and Lloyds, to suspend their advertising with the paper.

Asked whether the government should follow suit, Sir George Young said he would raise the matter urgently with his cabinet colleagues.

Andy Coulson, Rupert Murdoch, Rebekah Brooks The roles of Andy Coulson (l) and Rebekah Brooks (r) are expected to come under scrutiny by MPs

The Central Office of Information, which is in charge of government marketing, spent ?53,377 in the past year on adverts in the News of the World.

Meanwhile, the government has refused to bow to pressure to suspend consideration of a bid by the News of the World's parent company to take over broadcaster BSkyB.

Asking an urgent question in the Lords, shadow Lords leader Baroness Royal warned that refusing to do so would be seen as "incomprehensible both by the public and by News Corporation's advertisers and investors".

But Baroness Rawlings, speaking on behalf of the government, said Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt was confined to considering issues of media plurality when making his decision.

Murder victims

Labour are also continuing to call for Rebekah Brooks - News International chief executive and former editor of the News of the World - to resign.

On Wednesday, she received the backing of News International owner Rupert Murdoch who also said the allegations were "deplorable and unacceptable".

Mr Cameron has said "everybody at News International should ask themselves some searching questions", but he has come under personal pressure over his decision to hire another former News of the World editor, Andy Coulson, as his director of communications after he resigned from the paper in 2007 over the phone hacking scandal.

Allegations about the targeting of politicians and celebrities, including actor Hugh Grant and former Deputy Prime Minister Lord Prescott, have been known for some time.

But in recent days it has been claimed that the voicemail of murdered schoolgirl Milly Dowler was hacked by the News of the World, as well as at least one of the parents of Soham victims Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman.

It has also emerged that Chancellor George Osborne has also been informed by police that his name and home phone number had been found in notes kept by private investigator Glenn Mulcaire and the former News of the World reporter Clive Goodman.

A spokesman for the chancellor said there was no suggestion his phone had been hacked.


View the original article here

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Tory peer urges hacking inquiry

16 June 2011 Last updated at 17:16 GMT Lord Fowler called for a full independent inquiry into phone hacking

Former minister Norman Fowler has urged the government to hold an inquiry into the phone-hacking scandal, calling it a "conspiracy against the public".

In response, Baroness Rawlings said that establishing another investigation could harm those already under way.

Police are investigating claims News of the World staff illegally accessed the phone messages of public figures.

Meanwhile, News International has appointed a former High Court judge to administer its compensation scheme.

The company says Sir Charles Gray will be an independent adjudicator for victims of phone hacking.

During a debate in the Lords, Labour peer Lord Sugar said newspaper editors, owners and directors should all face prison sentences over the hacking.

He told the house: "It is ludicrous to suggest that the editor of a national newspaper is not aware of where the information came from.

"In the past a journalist was actually given a custodial sentence for phone hacking. Isn't it the case that the editor is responsible for what goes in the newspaper and he also should be given a custodial sentence and indeed the proprietor and the board of directors?"

Baroness Rawlings said: "When it comes to editors, I am afraid I am unaware of what happened there."

'Delicate point'

Former Health Secretary Lord Fowler, who is also a former journalist and newspaper editor, said the hacking had originally been dismissed as the work of one rogue reporter but evidence had since emerged that more than one newspaper had been involved.

Hugh Grant Hugh Grant has made calls for a privacy law to be introduced

He described the affair as "a massive conspiracy against the public", which the police and the Press Complaints Commission had been powerless to prevent.

Lord Fowler asked Lady Rawlings to give an assurance that the government would set up an independent inquiry into the phone hacking once criminal proceedings were complete.

Lady Rawlings said the government would monitor the outcomes of the current inquiries and "consider whether any further action will be necessary".

Meanwhile, the actor Hugh Grant says he has had enough of tabloid newspapers stealing people's privacy and claims only last month that he had to go to hospital and details were printed in two papers.

"People just need to know that when tabloids are complaining about injunctions etc infringing freedom of speech, what they're actually complaining about is loss of profit," he said in an interview with BBC Radio 4's PM programme.

Terrifying notes

Mr Grant said the Met Police had shown him "terrifying notes" from private investigator Glenn Mulcaire, who was convicted of hacking phones for the newspaper and knew "unbelievable details about friends, family, where they lived, my bank account details etc".

"I don't often come out of my trench but I am outraged by this and not only on my own behalf."

He added: "On balance we do need a privacy law rather than this present system where it is enshrined in our law via the European Bill of Human Rights and our own Bill of Human Rights by which you have to do it via a judge or via an injunction."

In January, the Metropolitan Police reopened its investigation into the News of the World hacking claims after criticism of its initial 2006 inquiry.

Some staff at the newspaper - owned by Rupert Murdoch's News International - are alleged to have hacked into the phone messages of public figures, including a number of MPs, from 2005 to 2006.

In 2007, the first police investigation led to the convictions and imprisonment of then News of the World royal editor Clive Goodman and private investigator Glenn Mulcaire, who was employed by the paper.

Five alleged victims have since reached out-of-court settlements with the newspaper.


View the original article here