Showing posts with label foreign. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreign. Show all posts

Friday, June 17, 2011

EU foreign chief defends budget

14 June 2011 Last updated at 19:38 GMT By Emma Griffiths Political reporter, BBC News Baroness Ashton Baroness Ashton said EU foreign ministers had raised no concerns about "mission creep" EU foreign minister Baroness Ashton has defended asking for a budget rise for her new External Action Service.

Her request for a 5.8% increase for the EU's new diplomatic service was described by the UK's minister for Europe as "somewhat ludicrous".

Baroness Ashton told peers she had made some savings but had not been given enough money to cover staff costs.

She also denied suggestions EU states were "jealous" of the EAS and were concerned about "mission creep".

Baroness Ashton - a former leader of the House of Lords, now the EU's foreign policy chief - returned to the UK Parliament on Tuesday for questions from the Lords EU Select Committee.

Criticism

She was made EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy in 2009 - a role created by the Lisbon Treaty.

She has since come in for some criticism - including from the French, Belgian and Austrian foreign ministers - on various issues.

Continue reading the main story
The amount of money that was transferred with them doesn't match the amount of money that I have to pay them”

End Quote Baroness Ashton Last month David Lidington, the UK's minister for Europe, criticised her request for a 5.8% budget rise and said the UK would need to see "the detailed workings".

He also suggested some EU diplomatic missions were trying to usurp the functions of national foreign ministries, saying London had sent out instructions to its embassies asking them to be "vigilant about any risk of competence creep" by EU delegations.

And Baroness Ashton has faced criticism in the British press about the cost, size and scope of the EAS.

She told peers she was "extremely conscious" of the need to effectively use resources - the EAS budget for 2011 was 475.8m euros (?404m).

'Different views'

She had implemented a 10% efficiency drive on budgets she could control she said and stressed many overseas EU staff worked, not for her but for the European Commission.

But she said there were costs she could not control and she had "inherited" staff from different institutions when the EAS was created, who had to be paid.

"The amount of money that was transferred with them doesn't match the amount of money that I have to pay them," she said.

She added that the creation of a new country, southern Sudan, had brought its own cost pressures and more resources were needed for Libya, Egypt, Tunisia.

'Foreign Office for Europe'

Baroness Ashton admitted there were "different views" across EU member states and institutions about what her role should be but said a general agreement had been reached.

"I'm creating a service for the member states, for the institutions, that will enable Europe when it wishes to speak as one, to speak as one more effectively than it did before."

Responding to suggestions the EAS was meant to be a "Foreign Office for Europe", she said it was not "a replacement of what countries do very well" but offered the chance to "bring together the common policies" of all 27 member states "and develop an approach that means you have more bang for your buck".

Continue reading the main story
There's been an enormous amount of back biting and people fighting their corners in Brussels”

End Quote Lord Roper Committee chairman She said work would be "complementary to" that done in individual EU countries' foreign offices and while the EAS could take the initiative, it would have to have the back-up of EU states to be effective.

Discussing reports that EU delegations were seeking to expand their responsibilities at the expense of member states, committee member Lord Plumb said he was surprised to hear there was "a certain amount of jealousy" between embassies and the EU.

She denied there was jealousy and said there had been a "dialogue" in some countries about how the two should co-ordinate effectively but that had been "worked out in many countries on the ground".

"If it went perfectly from day one it would be astonishing. I don't think or I've not had any challenges from any member state at all that we are doing some kind of 'mission creep' - nobody has said that."

She denied her initiatives had to be bland for fear of treading on the toes of EU member states: "I don't accept that - I'm really ambitious for what we can do." She said the only way to achieve things was to be as "ambitious as possible".

Committee chairman Lord Roper told the BBC Baroness Ashton had had an "unfair press".

He said the EAS had pulled together people who had worked for the European Council and European Commission and there had been "an enormous amount of back-biting and people fighting their corners in Brussels".

And he added: "There are obviously people who didn't get her job and who haven't been terribly charitable towards her."


View the original article here

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Fox challenges foreign aid pledge

17 May 2011 Last updated at 14:04 GMT Liam Fox (left) and David Cameron No 10 has said the UK's policy will not change despite Dr Fox's concerns Defence Secretary Liam Fox has challenged a plan to enshrine in law the UK's promise to spend 0.7% of its gross national income on overseas aid.

In a letter leaked to the Times, Dr Fox says he "cannot support the proposal in its current form".

A source close to Dr Fox said the issue was not the level of the target but how best to reflect this in law.

Downing Street said it remained fully committed to implementing its pledge in line with the coalition agreement.

The BBC understands Dr Fox's letter was written to Prime Minister David Cameron about five weeks ago.

The defence secretary said that "creating a statutory requirement to spend 0.7%" on overseas aid could lead to legal challenges and limit the government's options on where money was spent.

International aid is one of only a handful of areas, including health spending in England, being ringfenced from spending cuts over the next four years. Most other departments are seeing their budgets slashed - defence spending by 8% by 2015.

'Considered carefully'

BBC Radio 4's chief political correspondent, Norman Smith, said there would be a suspicion Dr Fox was "irked" that more money was going on aid projects when he is having to claw back spending at the Ministry of Defence.

Continue reading the main story But he added that Dr Fox's concerns, which are likely to anger the prime minister, were shared by other Conservative MPs who believed increasing the aid budget could not be squared with the closure of libraries and children's centres at home.

In the letter, the defence secretary called on Mr Cameron to put the principles, rather than specific commitments, in law following the example set for the military covenant announced on Monday.

Dr Fox wrote: "I have considered the issue carefully, and discussed it with [International Development Secretary] Andrew [Mitchell] and [Foreign Secretary] William Hague, but I cannot support the proposal in its current form.

"In 2009 the proportion of national income spent on ODA [official development assistance] was only 0.52%.

"The bill could limit HMG's [Her Majesty's Government] ability to change its mind about the pace at which it reaches the target in order to direct more resources toward other activities or programmes rather than aid."

A legal target, he added, would result in more "stringent" monitoring of how foreign aid is spent and this may "present risks" to his ability to get funding for certain priority activities from the conflict pool - a fund jointly run by the MoD, Foreign Office and Department for International Development to promote conflict prevention and resolution.

'Issue of trust' Graph showing how the UK government spends its money

The source close to Dr Fox said: "The defence secretary fully supports the principle of a 0.7% target on international aid. The issue is simply how best to reflect this in law."

Senior Conservative backbencher Patrick Mercer, who is a former infantry officer in the British Army, said he had some "sympathy" for Dr Fox's position - a view known to be shared by many on the right of the party.

"At a time when the armed forces are being cut and cut hard, when they're at war in Afghanistan, Pakistan and indeed in Libya, with other conflicts on the horizon, you can see why the defence secretary is concerned," he said.

But Labour, which along with the Lib Dems also back the commitment, accused Dr Fox of seeking to "mobilise opposition" to it and said legislation was needed to show the government could be "trusted" on the issue.

"There is now a shadow cast over an important manifesto commitment and something which was in the coalition agreement," deputy leader and shadow international development secretary Harriet Harman told the BBC.

"We back what the government said on that. What we have to do is make sure David Cameron insists his cabinet back it. You cannot be in the cabinet and be arguing for a breaking of manifesto promises."

This is not the first time that a private letter from the defence secretary to the prime minister has been leaked to the press.

Ahead of last year's defence review, concerns raised by Dr Fox about proposed cuts in defence spending - which at the time he said were "unsustainable" - entered the public domain. Dr Fox criticised the leak and ordered an inquiry.

'Fully committed'

The promise to spend 0.7% of national income on aid by 2013 was put in the Conservative manifesto before the last general election and then repeated in the coalition agreement.

Comparison of countries spending on foreign aid

A Downing Street spokesman said it was "fully committed to enacting the 0.7% commitment into law, in line with the coalition agreement".

The 0.7% commitment is an international aspiration first mooted by the United Nations in the 1970s and reaffirmed by the world's leading economies in 2002.

Aid and development charity Oxfam said Dr Fox was "wrong" to question the government's approach.

"British aid offers great value to the taxpayer," its chief executive Barbara Stocking said. "For little more than a penny in the tax pound we not only help those in need but also boost our standing in the world and increase our influence in the global corridors of power."

Following a review earlier this year, the government is to stop giving direct development aid to 16 countries - including China and Iraq.

Support for India - the largest recipient of UK aid - is being frozen while ministers have said the overall budget is being more "tightly focused" on those countries most in need such as Pakistan, Bangladesh and Ethiopia.

In future, levels of aid will also be decided in terms of impact and not cost - the most radical shift in policy since the Department for International Development was founded in 1997.


View the original article here