Showing posts with label criticise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label criticise. Show all posts

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Unions criticise school trip plan

2 July 2011 Last updated at 19:24 GMT Pupil and teacher Ministers say there is too much bureaucracy involved in organising school trips Teaching unions have criticised plans to make school trips easier to organise amid government fears about the over-zealous application of safety laws.

The Department for Education is publishing new guidance to help schools ditch "unnecessary paperwork", and has cut 150 pages of guidelines to eight.

But the National Union of Teachers (NUT) said it feared reducing best practice could lead to more accidents.

Education Secretary Michael Gove said it was a "more common sense" approach.

Amanda Brown, of the NUT, said: "What we wouldn't want to do is to see a reduction of guidance which could lead to a lot more accidents.

'Myths'

"What we want is advice which is very clear and straightforward but long enough to cover enough of the detail so that people do feel secure."

The NASUWT teachers' union said cutting back guidance could reduce parents' confidence and make teachers more nervous about school trips because it provided a safeguard.

Continue reading the main story
The dilution of guidance for schools is likely to reduce rather than increase the number of educational visits”

End Quote Chris Keates NASUWT teachers' union "The decision to scrap over 140 pages of guidance is potentially reckless and could increase litigation against schools and teachers," said general secretary Chris Keates.

"There is no evidence demonstrating the need for the previous guidance to be abandoned, and no educational reason for doing so.

"Schools and teachers organise educational visits when it is clear that there is an opportunity to enhance and enrich pupils' learning and when they assure themselves that children will be safe.

'Crazy situation'

"The dilution of guidance for schools is likely to reduce rather than increase the number of educational visits."

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said it hoped the new guidelines would dispel legal "myths".

Chairman Judith Hackitt told the BBC it was "time to out those who hide behind red tape and procedures and often blame us and health and safety as the reason why they can't do these things".

She said guidelines had ended up being overly bureaucratic because of a fear of civil litigation, cost-cutting and because it was an easy way to avoid work that was regarded as more difficult.

Teachers were intelligent people and should be trusted to use their common sense, she added.

Ministers said school trips could broaden children's horizons but fear of prosecution was too often used as an excuse not to organise them.

In the past five years only two cases had been brought against schools for breaches of health and safety law on a visit, they said.

Employment minister Chris Grayling said: "We've got a crazy situation at the moment where, very often, headteachers and teachers think that actually the rules are such that it's not a good idea to plan school trips.

"There's too much bureaucracy, too many health and safety rules and a risk of prosecution if something goes wrong," he told the BBC.

"There is no reason - and never was - why children should be prevented from going on school trips by over-enthusiastic misinterpretation of rules," he said.

A Labour Party spokesman said health and safety rules needed to be applied sensibly.

The new guidelines clarify that written parental consent is not needed for each activity and encourage schools to use a new one-off consent form signed once when a child starts at a school.


View the original article here

Saturday, July 2, 2011

MPs criticise forensics closure

30 June 2011 Last updated at 23:43 GMT By Paul Rincon Science Editor, BBC News Website Forensic scientist The government wants the private sector to fill the gap left by the FSS The UK government did not give sufficient consideration to the wider impacts of closing the Forensic Science Service, an MPs' inquiry has concluded.

Implications for criminal justice, research and evidence archives were "hastily overlooked" for financial reasons, the report argues.

The FSS analyses evidence from crime scenes in England and Wales. The report calls for its closure to be delayed.

The government said it did not accept the report's findings.

The FSS had been losing about ?2m a month and was at risk of falling into administration, which prompted the government to announce plans to close the service and sell or transfer many of its operations.

But critics argue that criminal justice - and innovation in forensic research - will suffer as a result of the closure.

They say an over-emphasis on profits could damage the quality of science, compromising forensic evidence used in court.

Continue reading the main story
We don't agree with the committee's report. It mis-states a number of very significant points”

End Quote James Brokenshire MP Crime and security minister The MPs agreed with the government's assessment that administration was undesirable, but they said the decision should never have been taken purely on commercial and legal grounds.

The committee, chaired by Labour MP Andrew Miller, argues that the current timeline for closure is unlikely to ensure an orderly transition.

It urges the government to extend the March 2012 deadline by at least six months.

"Things have to happen, otherwise we're going to run the risk of damaging justice in this country," Mr Miller told BBC News.

The report urges against breaking up the FSS' evidence archives which hold about 1.78 million case files and are vital for revisiting "cold cases".

The government wants private enterprise, which currently accounts for 40% of forensic service provision, to fill the gap left behind by the FSS.

'Stabilising strategy'

But police forces have been bringing forensic work in-house in order to make cost savings. The committee viewed this practice of "in-sourcing" as an impediment to the future expansion of the private forensics market.

Mr Miller commented: "We now call on the government to stabilise the market, curbing police in-sourcing, and come up with a sensible strategy for forensic science research and provision in England and Wales."

Earlier this year, crime and security minister James Brokenshire confirmed the external forensics market was likely to contract from ?170m to ?110m by 2015. But the report raises the possibility that it could fall to the 2015 figure sooner because police cuts have yet to bite.

Responding to the MPs' inquiry, Mr Brokenshire commented: "We don't agree with the committee's report. It mis-states a number of very significant points.

"Our focus remains on providing continued high quality forensic services to the justice system now and in the future. We remain confident that our plans for winding down the FSS will deliver this."

During oral evidence to the inquiry, it emerged that the Home Office did not consult its chief scientific adviser in detail over the closure. The committee criticised the lack of consultation undertaken by the Home Office when coming to its decision.

Police labs

A spokesperson for LGC, the UK's biggest private forensics provider, commented: "We're pleased that the select committee has focused on the need for stability in the market, the contribution that private companies can make and the need for high quality forensic science."

But the statement adds: "We are concerned that any delay in the wind-down of the FSS would simply destabilise the market still further. What we need is to stick to the timetable so that private providers can plan and invest with confidence."

Continue reading the main story
There is a definite possibility that you are going to increase the number of miscarriages of justice”

End Quote Professor Peter Gill University of Strathclyde Professor Peter Gill, a forensic scientist from Strathclyde University, told BBC News: "[Forensic science] needs a lot of nurturing and looking after. Otherwise, there is a definite possibility that you are going to increase the number of miscarriages of justice."

"The problem is that this is now a fait accompli... you couldn't put the FSS back together now. The real issue is what's going to happen next."

Critics of in-sourcing voice concerns about quality standards in police labs and about impartiality - pointing out that complications could arise from the police acting as both customer and provider of forensic services.

But commentators in the police cite the example of fingerprinting, which has long been operated from within forces without significant controversy.

They argue that the boundaries between in-sourcing and out-sourcing are already somewhat blurred, with police employees being responsible for managing crime scenes and for forensic submissions.

Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own publicly-funded forensic science providers: the Scottish Police Services Authority (SPSA) Forensic Services and Forensic Science Northern Ireland (FSNI).

Paul.Rincon-INTERNET@bbc.co.uk


View the original article here